| Number | Player |
| 1 | Elmer Lach RC |
| 2 | Paul Meger RC |
| 3 | Emile “Butch” Bouchard RC |
| 4 | Maurice “Rocket” Richard RC |
| 5 | Bert Olmstead RC |
| 6 | Jim “Bud” MacPherson RC |
| 7 | Tom Johnson RC |
| 8 | Paul Masnick RC |
| 9 | Calum MacKay RC |
| 10 | Doug Harvey RC |
| 11 | Ken Mosdell RC |
| 12 | Floyd Curry RC |
| 13 | Billy Reay RC |
| 14 | Bernie “Boom-Boom” Geoffrion RC |
| 15 | Gerry McNeil RC |
| 16 | Dick Gamble RC |
| 17 | Gerry Couture RC |
| 18 | Ross Lowe RC |
| 19 | Jim Henry RC |
| 20 | Vic Lynn RC |
| 21 | Walter “Gus” Kyle RC |
| 22 | Ed Sandford RC |
| 23 | Murray Henderson RC |
| 24 | Dunc Fisher RC |
| 25 | Hal Laycoe RC |
| 26 | Bill Quackenbush RC |
| 27 | George “Red” Sullivan RC |
| 28 | Woody Dumart RC |
| 29 | Milt Schmidt RC |
| 30 | Adam Brown RC |
| 31 | Pentti Lund RC |
| 32 | Ray Barry RC |
| 33 | Ed Kryzanowski RC |
| 34 | Johnny Peirson RC |
| 35 | Lorne Ferguson RC |
| 36 | Clare Raglan RC |
| 37 | Bill Gadsby RC |
| 38 | Al Dewsbury RC |
| 39 | Clare Martin RC |
| 40 | Gus Bodnar RC |
| 41 | Jim Peters RC |
| 42 | Armand “Bep” Guidolin RC |
| 43 | George “Hully” Gee RC |
| 44 | Jim McFadden RC |
| 45 | Fred Hucul RC |
| 46 | Lee Fogolin RC |
| 47 | Harry Lumley RC |
| 48 | Doug Bentley RC |
| 49 | Bill Mosienko RC |
| 50 | Roy Conacher RC |
| 51 | Pete Babando RC |
| 52 | Gerry McNeil RC [The Winning Goal] |
| 53 | Jack Stewart RC |
| 54 | Marty Pavelich RC |
| 55 | Leonard “Red” Kelly RC |
| 56 | Ted Lindsay RC |
| 57 | Glen Skov RC |
| 58 | Benny Woit RC |
| 59 | Tony Leswick RC |
| 60 | Fred Glover RC |
| 61 | Terry Sawchuk RC |
| 62 | Vic Stasiuk RC |
| 63 | Alex Delvecchio RC |
| 64 | Sid Abel RC |
| 65 | Metro Prystai RC |
| 66 | Gordie Howe RC |
| 67 | Bob Goldham RC |
| 68 | Marcel Pronovost RC |
| 69 | Leo Reise RC |
| 70 | Harry Watson RC |
| 71 | Danny Lewicki RC |
| 72 | Howie Meeker RC |
| 73 | Gus Mortson RC |
| 74 | Joe Klukay RC |
| 75 | Walter “Turk” Broda |
| 76 | Al Rollins RC |
| 77 | Bill Juzda RC |
| 78 | Ray Timgren RC |
| 79 | Hugh Bolton RC |
| 80 | Fern Flaman RC |
| 81 | Max Bentley RC |
| 82 | Jim Thomson RC |
| 83 | Fleming Mackell RC |
| 84 | Sid Smith RC |
| 85 | Cal Gardner RC |
| 86 | Ted Kennedy RC |
| 87 | Tod Sloan RC |
| 88 | Bob Solinger RC |
| 89 | Frank Eddolls RC |
| 90 | Jack Evans RC |
| 91 | Hy Buller RC |
| 92 | Steve Kraftcheck RC |
| 93 | Don Raleigh RC |
| 94 | Allan Stanley RC |
| 95 | Paul Ronty RC |
| 96 | Edgar Laprade RC |
| 97 | Nick Mickoski RC |
| 98 | Jack McLeod RC |
| 99 | Gaye Stewart RC |
| 100 | Wally Hergesheimer RC |
| 101 | Ed Kullman RC |
| 102 | Ed Slowinski RC |
| 103 | Reggie Sinclair RC |
| 104 | Chuck Rayner RC |
| 105 | Jim Conacher RC |