| Number | Player |
| 1 | Lester Patrick [All-time Greats] |
| 2 | Paddy Moran [All-time Greats] |
| 3 | Joe Malone [All-time Greats] |
| 4 | Ernie “Moose” Johnson [All-time Greats] |
| 5 | Nels Stewart [All-time Greats] |
| 6 | Bill Hay RC |
| 7 | Eddie Shack |
| 8 | Cy Denneny RC [All-time Greats] |
| 9 | Jim Morrison |
| 10 | Bill Cook [All-time Greats] |
| 11 | Johnny Bucyk |
| 12 | Murray Balfour |
| 13 | Leo Labine |
| 14 | Stan Mikita RC |
| 15 | George Hay RC [All-time Greats] |
| 16 | Mervyn “Red” Dutton [All-time Greats] |
| 17 | Dickie Boon RC [All-time Greats] |
| 18 | George “Red” Sullivan |
| 19 | Georges Vezina [All-time Greats] |
| 20 | Eddie Shore [All-time Greats] |
| 21 | Ed Litzenberger |
| 22 | Bill Gadsby |
| 23 | Elmer Vasko |
| 24 | Charlie Burns |
| 25 | Glenn Hall |
| 26 | Aubrey “Dit” Clapper [All-time Greats] |
| 27 | Art Ross [All-time Greats] |
| 28 | Jerry Toppazzini |
| 29 | Frank Boucher [All-time Greats] |
| 30 | Jack Evans |
| 31 | Jean-Guy Gendron |
| 32 | Chuck Gardiner RC [All-time Greats] |
| 33 | Ab McDonald |
| 34 | Frank Frederickson RC [All-time Greats] |
| 35 | Frank Nighbor RC [All-time Greats] |
| 36 | Lorne “Gump” Worsley |
| 37 | Dean Prentice |
| 38 | Hugh Lehman RC [All-time Greats] |
| 39 | Jack McCartan RC |
| 40 | Don McKenney |
| 41 | Ron Murphy |
| 42 | Andy Hebenton |
| 43 | Don Simmons |
| 44 | Herb Gardiner RC [All-time Greats] |
| 45 | Andy Bathgate |
| 46 | Fred “Cyclone” Taylor [All-time Greats] |
| 47 | Francis “King” Clancy [All-time Greats] |
| 48 | Edward “Newsy” Lalonde [All-time Greats] |
| 49 | Harry Howell |
| 50 | Ken Schinkel RC |
| 51 | Tod Sloan |
| 52 | Doug Mohns |
| 53 | Camille Henry |
| 54 | Bronco Horvath |
| 55 | Cecil “Tiny” Thompson [All-time Greats] |
| 56 | Bob Armstrong |
| 57 | Fern Flaman |
| 58 | Bobby Hull |
| 59 | Howie Morenz [All-time Greats] |
| 60 | Dick Irvin RC [All-time Greats] |
| 61 | Lou Fontinato |
| 62 | Leo Boivin |
| 63 | Moose Goheen RC [All-time Greats] |
| 64 | Al Arbour |
| 65 | Pierre Pilote |
| 66 | Vic Stasiuk |